| . | season | winner | opponent | venue | competition name |
| 1 | 1969 | Hampstead (Middlesex) | Pocklington Pixies (Yorkshire) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 2 | 1970 | Cheltenham (Gloucestershire) | Stockport (Cheshire) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 3 | 1971 | Blackheath (Kent) | Ealing (Middlesex) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 4 | 1972 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | Brentham (Middlesex) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 5 | 1973 | Wolverhampton (Staffordshire) | The Mote (Kent) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 6 | 1974 | Sunbury (Middlesex) | Tunbridge Wells (Kent) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 7 | 1975 | York (Yorkshire) | Blackpool (Lancashire) | Lord's | DH Robins Cup |
| 8 | 1976 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | Dulwich (Surrey) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 9 | 1977 | Southgate (Middlesex) | Bowdon (Cheshire) | Edgbaston | John Haig Trophy |
| 10 | 1978 | Cheltenham (Gloucestershire) | Bishop's Stortford (Hertfordshire) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 11 | 1979 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | Reading (Berkshire) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 12 | 1980 | Moseley (Warwickshire) | Gosport Borough (Hampshire) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 13 | 1981 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | Blackheath (Kent) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 14 | 1982 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | Finchley (Middlesex) | Lord's | John Haig Trophy |
| 15 | 1983 | Shrewsbury (Shropshire) | Hastings & St Leonard's Priory (Sussex) | Lord's | William Younger Cup |
| 16 | 1984 | Old Hill (Worcerstershire) | Bishop's Stortford (Hertfordshire) | Lord's | William Younger Cup |
| 17 | 1985 | Old Hill (Worcestershire) | Reading (Berkshire) | Lord's | William Younger Cup |
| 18 | 1986 | Stourbridge (Worcestershire) | Weston-super-Mare (Somerset) | Lord's | William Younger Cup |
| 19 | 1987 | Old Hill (Worcestershire) | Teddington (Middlesex) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 20 | 1988 | Enfield (Middlesex) | Wolverhampton (Staffordshire) | replayed at Edgbaston | Cockspur Cup |
| 21 | 1989 | Teddington (Middlesex) | Old Hill (Worcestershire) | replayed at Edgbaston | Cockspur Cup |
| 22 | 1990 | Blackpool (Lancashire) | Cheam (Surrey) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 23 | 1991 | Teddington (Middlesex) | Walsall (Staffordshire) | Lord's | Club Cricket Championship |
| 24 | 1992 | Optimists (Gloucestershire) | Kendal (Cumbria) | Lord's | Club Cricket Championship |
| 25 | 1993 | Old Hill (Worcestershire) | West Bromwich Dartmouth (Staffordshire) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 26 | 1994 | Chorley (Lancashire) | Ealing (Middlesex) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 27 | 1995 | Chorley (Lancashire) | Clifton Flax Bourton (Somerset) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 28 | 1996 | Walsall (Staffordshire) | Chorley (Lancashire) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 29 | 1997 | Eastbourne (Sussex) | Harrogate (Yorkshire) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 30 | 1998 | Doncaster Town (Yorkshire) | Bath (Somerset) | Lord's | Abbot Ale Cup |
| 31 | 1999 | Wolverhampton (Staffordshire) | Teddington (Middlesex) | Lord's | Club Cricket Championship |
| 32 | 2000 | Sheffield Collegiate (Yorkshire) | Eastbourne (Sussex) | replayed at Southgate | Club Cricket Championship |
| 33 | 2001 | Bramhall (Cheshire) | Bath (Somerset) | Lord's | Club Cricket Championship sponsored by play-cricket.com |
| 34 | 2002 | Saffron Walden (Essex) | Barnt Green (Worcestershire) | Edgbaston | Club Cricket Championship sponsored by play-cricket.com |
| 35 | 2003 | Sandiacre Town (Derbyshire) | Bath (Somerset) | Lord's | Club Cricket Championship |
| 36 | 2004 | Kibworth (Leicestershire) | Ockbrook & Borrowash (Derbyshire) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 37 | 2005 | Horsham (Sussex) | Barnt Green (Worcestershire) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 38 | 2006 | South Northumberland (Northumberland) | Bromley (Kent) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 39 | 2007 | Bromley (Kent) | Kibworth (Leicestershire) | Lord's | Cockspur Cup |
| 40 | 2008 | Kibworth (Leicestershire) | Malden Wanderers (Surrey) | replayed at Southgate | Cockspur Cup |
| 41 | 2009 | Chester-le-Street (Durham) | Spencer (Surrey) | Derby | ECB National Club Championship |
| 42 | 2010 | South Northumberland (Northumberland) | Ealing (Middlesex) | Derby | ECB National Club Championship |
| 43 | 2011 | Shrewsbury (Shropshire) | Cambridge Granta (Cambridgeshire) | Derby | ECB National Club Championship |
| 44 | 2012 | York (Yorkshire) | Wanstead & Snaresbrook (Essex) | Derby | Kingfisher Beer Cup |
| 45 | 2013 | West Indian Cavaliers (Nottinghamshire) | Ealing (Middlesex) | Chester le Street | ECB National Club Championship |
| 46 | 2014 | Sandiacre Town (Derbyshire) | Sunbury (Middlesex) | Bristol | Royal London Club Championship |
| 47 | 2015 | Blackheath (Kent) | Northern (Lancashire) | Beckenham | Royal London Club Championship |
| 48 | 2016 | South Northumberland (Northumberland) | Swardeston (Norfolk) | Northampton | Royal London Club Championship |
| 49 | 2017 | Wanstead & Snaresbrook (Essex) | Ormskirk (Lancashire) | Chelmsford | Royal London Club Championship |
| 50 | 2018 | Richmondshire (Yorkshire) | Stanmore (Middlesex) | Bristol | Royal London Club Championship |
| 51 | 2019 | Swardeston (Norfolk) | Nantwich (Cheshire) | Lord's | Royal London Club Championship |
| . | 2020 | no competition owing to the COVID-19 pandemic | |||
| 52 | 2021 | Bath (Somerset) | Sandiacre Town (Derbyshire) | Wormsley | Royal London Club Championship |
| times | wins in finals | years |
times |
defeats in finals | years |
| 5 | Scarborough (Yorkshire) | 1972, 1976, 1979, 1981, 1982 | 4 | Ealing (Middlesex) | 1971, 1994, 2010, 2013 |
| . | . | . | . | . | . |
| 4 | Old Hill (Worcerstershire) | 1984, 1985, 1987, 1993 | 3 | Bath (Somerset) | 1998, 2001, 2003 |
| . | . | . | . | . | . |
| 3 | South Northumberland (Northumberland) | 2006, 2010, 2016 | 2 | Barnt Green (Worcestershire) | 2002, 2005 |
| . | . | . | . | Bishop's Stortford (Hertfordshire) | 1978, 1984 |
| 2 | Blackheath (Kent) | 1971, 2015 | . | Reading (Berkshire) | 1979, 1985 |
| . | Cheltenham (Gloucestershire) | 1970, 1978 | . | Teddington (Middlesex) | 1987, 1999 |
| . | Chorley (Lancashire) | 1994, 1995 | . | . | . |
| . | Kibworth (Leicestershire) | 2004, 2008 | 1 | Blackheath (Kent) | 1981 |
| . | Sandiacre Town (Derbyshire) | 2003, 2014 | . | Blackpool (Lancashire) | 1975 |
| . | Shrewsbury (Shropshire) | 1983, 2011 | . | Bowdon (Cheshire) | 1977 |
| . | Teddington (Middlesex) | 1989, 1991 | . | Brentham (Middlesex) | 1972 |
| . | Wolverhampton (Staffordshire) | 1973, 1999 | . | Bromley (Kent) | 2006 |
| . | York (Yorkshire) | 1975, 2012 | . | Cambridge Granta (Cambridgeshire) | 2011 |
| . | . | . | . | Cheam (Surrey) | 1990 |
| .1 | Bath (Somerset) | 2021 | . | Chorley (Lancashire) | 1996 |
| . | Blackpool (Lancashire) | 1990 | . | Clifton Flax Bourton (Somerset) | 1995 |
| . | Bramhall (Cheshire) | 2001 | . | Dulwich (Surrey) | 1976 |
| . | Bromley (Kent) | 2007 | . | Eastbourne (Sussex) | 2000 |
| . | Chester-le-Street (Durham) | 2009 | . | Finchley (Middlesex) | 1982 |
| . | Doncaster Town (Yorkshire) | 1998 | . | Gosport Borough (Hampshire) | 1980 |
| . | Eastbourne (Sussex) | 1997 | . | Harrogate (Yorkshire) | 1997 |
| . | Enfield (Middlesex) | 1988 | . | Hastings & St Leonard's Priory (Sussex) | 1983 |
| . | Hampstead (Middlesex) | 1969 | . | Kendal (Cumbria) | 1992 |
| . | Horsham (Sussex) | 2005 | . | Kibworth (Leicestershire) | 2007 |
| . | Moseley (Warwickshire) | 1980 | . | Malden Wanderers (Surrey) | 2008 |
| . | Optimists (Gloucestershire) | 1992 | . | Nantwich (Cheshire) | 2019 |
| . | Richmondshire (Yorkshire) | 2018 | . | Northern (Lancashire) | 2015 |
| . | Saffron Walden (Essex) | 2002 | . | Ockbrook & Borrowash (Derbyshire) | 2004 |
| . | Sheffield Collegiate (Yorkshire) | 2000 | . | Old Hill (Worcestershire) | 1989 |
| . | Southgate (Middlesex) | 1977 | . | Ormskirk (Lancashire) | 2017 |
| . | Stourbridge (Worcestershire) | 1986 | . | Pocklington Pixies (Yorkshire) | 1969 |
| . | Sunbury (Middlesex) | 1974 | . | Sandiacre Town (Derbyshire) | 2021 |
| . | Swardeston (Norfolk) | 2019 | . | Spencer (Surrey) | 2009 |
| . | Walsall (Staffordshire) | 1996 | . | Stanmore (Middlesex) | 2018 |
| . | Wanstead & Snaresbrook (Essex) | 2017 | . | Stockport (Cheshire) | 1970 |
| . | . | . | . | Sunbury (Middlesex) | 2014 |
| . | . | . | . | Swardeston (Norfolk) | 2016 |
| . | . | . | . | The Mote (Kent) | 1973 |
| . | . | . | . | Tunbridge Wells (Kent) | 1974 |
| . | . | . | . | Walsall (Staffordshire) | 1991 |
| . | . | . | . | Wanstead & Snaresbrook (Essex) | 2012 |
| . | . | . | . | West Bromwich Dartmouth (Staffordshire) | 1993 |
| . | . | . | . | Weston-super-Mare (Somerset) | 1986 |
| Wolverhampton (Staffordshire) | 1988 |
